Secret Sandwich Society

Row 1

103 Keller Ave
Fayetteville, WV 25840
(304) 574-4777
Sandwiches, Arcade
$ $
Mon, Wed–Sun: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM


Foursquare Tips

  • Great sandwiches. Service was a little slow but definitely worth the wait. Is the kind of place that should be on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives
  • Meat comes from a local farm and is roasted on site. Cutlery is biodegradable. Local draft beer. Good vegetarian sandwiches. Very unique sandwiches
  • The Moroccan chicken stew over a bowl of couscous was like booyah for my belly!! Nom nom nom and topped off with a tasty pitcher of porter!
  • Awesome pimento fries!!!
  • Try the Ulysses. Peach jam is delicious. You can also order the fabulous breakfast sandwiches all day!
  • With my GNO girls!!
  • There is more that isn't on the menu. Everything is excellent. Dont nitpick over specific ingredients because they're probably nothing like you've had, before.
  • Long wait great food
  • Our appetizer - cheese fries - was a mound of fries covered in pimento cheese. The Rawhide Burger is a spicy delicacy featuring jalapeos, fried egg over-easy and aioli sauce. It will make you sweat.
  • Amazing chocolate cheesecake, definitely a keeper.
  • Simple comforting experience. Its nice to have a great sandwich cut with a hoppy beer.
  • Awesome sweet tea and $1 PBR!
  • Breakfast & Lunch menu available ALL DAY! get your lunch to go when you're getting your bfast, and your entire order is 10% off! Bring your own coffee cup for .25 off your coffee- see you soon!
  • Good beer list, English-style pint glasses, and a pic of George Washington on the wall. Perfect.
  • Nice curation on the beer last. Good choices across styles and a good mix of local and national brands.
  • Show off your patriotism by ordering the Fillmore or Lincoln. All of the sandwiches are named after U.S. presidents at this speakeasy-type joint.
  • Soup of the day.
  • Servers dont take food allergies seriously. Learned this the hard way when getting nuts and milk in my salad - after mentioning milk and nut allergies... Felt so sick. Never again.
  • Check out the live music upstairs! Quirky setting with improv electric ukelele and mandolin from local climbers!
  • Everything is amazing! My favorite is the Lafayette :)