Saddle River Inn
Map: Surroundings & Nearby
Ask for the Nixon table.
Everything tended to be a little more cooked than ordered. Maybe ask for things a little on the rare side (including scallops)
One of the most disappointing dining experiences I've ever had. We were a party of six which brought over $1000 worth of wine only to have the sequences mixed up. Plus the food sucked. Simple as that.