Italian Gator (Pizza By The Slice)
Map: Surroundings & Nearby
A late-night favorite of the midtown crowd but it's honestly good anytime. Literally a hole in the wall. They use a brick oven for a crispy New York-style slice. Not fancy or cheap, but great pizza.
Best pizza in Midtown
Best Pizza ever!
Get the meatball sub on Tuesday - it takes a while to make so call ahead