Gandolfo's New York Deli

Row 1

224 E Market St
Smithfield, NC 27577
(919) 934-9100
Deli / Bodega
Mon–Fri, Sun: 7:00 AM–9:00 PM Sat: 8:00 AM–3:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Knuckle Sandwich ridiculously good!
  • One of my favorite spots in Downtown Smithfield for lunch.
  • Best NY style subs in the south
  • Best sammiches around!
  • Authentic NEW YORK STYLE! Best around
  • Some of the best Chicken Salad I've ever had.
  • Try the ruben. Its to die for.
  • Worth the wait! best sub I've had since moving to nc! =)
  • The pastrami egg and cheese sandwich is amazing make sure to order it overstuffed
  • The New York Giant. It's not on the menu. Pastrami, pickles, yellow mustard subs. Brings back memories when I had it as a kid.
  • Name change on Facebook to Gotham's Deli of Smithfield NC
  • my go to sandwich is the whitestone bridge - chicken and bacon + add a little Dijon, goes perfect with one of their sandwich pickles!
  • Best potato salad I've ever had! Our family loves the Buffalo Bill sandwiches.
  • The Godfather is my favorite!
  • It is an awesome sandwich experience!
  • So delicious. Love this place. Awesome setting, great service.
  • A taste of NY in Johnston County. Who knew? The I Love NY sandwich was excellent!
  • Just like home :)
  • The best place in town to come sit down relax and bs with the folks.
  • We were excited to try this place...but they ran out of sub rolls...a sub place...with no sub rolls?????????? Maybe next time!