Eddie's Sweet Shop

Row 1

Details
10529 Metropolitan Ave (at 72nd Rd)
Forest Hills, NY 11375
(718) 520-8514
Ice Cream
$
Hours
Tue–Fri: 1:00 PM–11:30 PM Sat–Sun: Noon–11:30 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • As classic as a scoop shop/soda fountain gets. Great milkshakes and ice cream sundaes that load on the toppings; don't skip the hot fudge or homemade whipped cream.
  • "Every flavor is handcrafted, but the standout is maple walnut: rich, buttery, filled with nuts. Hot fudge is unnecessary on a scoop this beautiful" ($5.50).
  • If you're looking to take a trip in the wayback machine to a late 1920s ice cream parlor, then Eddie's Sweet Shop is the place for you! Old-timey goodness.
  • Get the vanilla malted milkshake! A classic treat that's very well done here at eddies. I love the 1950s atmosphere. Very rare. Also, it's Zagat rated :)
  • They're filming boardwalk empire today at Eddie's sweetshop
  • I always hear complaints another the service, but I've never had a problem. They are super nice and the ice cream is delicious and fairly priced!!
  • Their homemade fudge is like crack. I don't even like fudge & I wanted to lick it off the plate, well, we did. :X The ice creams are delectable, but make sure to add the fudge. You won't regret it.
  • Get the Jessica-coffee ice cream, sliced bananas, hot fudge, caramel, whipped cream and cinnamon
  • Meet the Banana Royal Sundae: Three scoops. Bananas. Sprinkles. Whipped cream. Cherries. Syrup. Walnuts. NO EXCUSES.
  • Located in family-oriented Forest Hills, Eddie's is a retro ice cream parlor that serves up all-but-forgotten candies and to-die-for sundaes. The decor includes antique and authentic pieces.
  • An adorable date spot, then finish it off with a stroll through beautiful forest hills.
  • Absolutely the best Banana Royale I've ever had!
  • This place is historic and has been open in the neighborhood for generations for good reason. Hot fudge is heaven on earth and is perfect with their homemade vanilla chocolate chip ice cream. Amazing!
  • The chocolate malted milk shake because action bronson said so. #fuckthatsdelicious
  • Go back in time in at this adorable spot and enjoy all of their homemade treats.
  • Could eat the marshmallow topping by the bucket full. Probably end up losing a leg through diabetes - but it'd be worth it.
  • Yaammmyyyy!!!!!!
  • The banana ice cream is seriously the best you'll ever have. Yum!
  • Try the Butter pecan with Hot fudge n Almonds...
  • A Forest Hills institution. Fantastic old school ice cream parlor. Home made ice cream and $5 shakes - what more could you ask for?