Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies

Row 1

Details
185 Van Dyke St (at Ferris St)
Brooklyn, NY 11231
(888) 450-5463
Pie Shop, Desserts
$
Hours
Mon–Fri: Noon–7:00 PM Sat–Sun: 11:00 AM–7:00 PM

Around the Web

Foursquare Tips

  • Have you tried the Swingle? It's a key lime pietart lime curd, buttery graham cracker crust, and allfrozen and enrobed in high-end dark chocolate, then shoved on a popsicle stick.
  • I don't even like key lime pie - and this is outstanding! Just don't let your baby get first dibs.
  • Get the Swingle, a miniature frozen chocolate-dipped key lime pie on a stick.
  • I am making this a tip not because the klp is so good (although it's tasty) but because the view from behind the store, across the water, makes your heart swell with love of New York.
  • A swingle is a bit of heaven on a stick.
  • The finest key lime pies in NYC. You can get whole and single-serving pies as well as a frozen, chocolate-dripped pie on a stick: the Swingle.
  • For the perfect amount of the most perfect Key Lime Pie, order the Swingle, a key lime pie tart on a stick, dipped in Belgian dark chocolate.
  • The swingle is amazing... But the raspberry swingle is downright transcendent.
  • Summertime classic. Grab a 4" pie, don't share it with anyone, and walk to the water.
  • Don't be tempted by the chocolate covered key lime pie. The original is amazing on its own .
  • I'm still thinking about it long after I gobbled it all down! Delicious, highly recommended!
  • Unless you're a dark chocolate lover, pass on the swizzle. The intense flavor of the cocoa takes away from the pure goodness of the key lime pie. The tart is the best way to go.
  • swingle [swin-guhl] (n.): A frozen key lime pie dipped in chocolate, on a stick. Best enjoyed with a view of the Statue of Liberty from a pier in Red Hook.
  • swingle [swin-guhl] (n.): A frozen key lime pie dipped in chocolate, on a stick. Best enjoyed with a view of the Statue of Liberty from a pier in Red Hook.
  • Tart, not too sweet, cool, creamy (not gloopy!) and sitting in a simple old-fashioned graham cracker crust with a tender crumb, this KLP is pretty damn fabulous. Bonus: resorty benches by the water.
  • Go for the swingle
  • Try the Swingle
  • Call ahead- they are pretty laid back with their hours
  • Get the swingle! Frozen key lime pie covered in chocolate on a stick. Delicious.
  • The best Key Lime Pie this side of the Mason Dixon.