Schwarz Supper Club

Row 1

W1688 Sheboygan Rd
New Holstein, WI 53061
(920) 894-3598
American, Steakhouse
$ $
Wed–Thu: 3:00 PM–8:30 PM Fri–Sat: 3:00 PM–9:30 PM Sun: 2:00 PM–9:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Arrive an hour early, have 3 stiff vodkas then order the cowboy medium rare or surf n turf for only $40.
  • Zero cell service for us cellular. Wifi needed.
  • Get your husband to ask the waitress for Blue Balls.... They are yummie.... And don't forget the Onion Stack!!!
  • Prime rib!! oops
  • Sirloin tips with mushrooms are a heavily delight...old fashions are pretty good too!
  • appetizer -- onion rings.. aka slices of cooked onions & a pile of crusty pieces.. needed a spoon! dinner was delicious and staff was overall great but quite judgmental about our happy party.
  • Onion rings are a must!! All their steaks are great.... The wait is totally worth it!!
  • Sirloin tips and battered shrimp. One of the best meals you can find in the area!
  • I want to be the mayor
  • Ribeye, medium-well. There are no other options.
  • Prim rib!!!!!!