Sam's Bar and Restaurant

Row 1

36 Newtown Ln
East Hampton, NY 11937
(631) 324-5900
Italian, Pizza
$ $
Mon–Thu, Sun: 5:00 PM–10:30 PM Fri–Sat: 5:00 PM–11:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Best pizza in the Hamptons!
  • Best Pizza. Period. Topped only by the a great Bar Tender and owner, Graham. Kid friendly so it gets a little noisy but always a hit when you want good food, good prices and even great drinks. Yum.
  • Great place to cool off, after being at the beach. Located in the middle of the village. Gram, he's a good source for information.
  • No frills pizza place.
  • Tnt pizza is bomb!
  • Tasty, hearty good. Relaxed, non-Hamptons type of feel.
  • Best pizza; maybe anywhere. Note though that they may have changed the mushrooms on the pizza (April May 2015) which would be a huge mistake. Stay tuned for updates.
  • The only good thing about down town east hampton. I approve of this pizza
  • I love how dumpy it is on the inside. Great break from all that pretentious Hamptons nonsense. And they make a solid chicken parm hero!
  • The Aloha Hawaiin pie is delish!!!
  • Grab a cozy booth and escape the Hamptons pretension at Sam's. Its bar-style pizza and baked clams are both fantastic.
  • The pizzas here are really good!
  • Everything was so amazing
  • I am a pizza snob and this has its own unique flavor that's amazing. Get the Roses Pizza
  • tomato sauce, cheese and the abundance of diced garlic. To top it all off, the crust is just perfect - flavorful and crispy... but not burnt. Will come back every time I come out to Easthampton!
  • OMG, this place is AMAZING. The pizza is phenomenal. The Greek pizza is better than my other fave, the El Greco (sorry Tappo, I still love you). Love the
  • An institution in East Hampton and not going away soon. Building is for sale, but the restaurant has a long term lease.
  • The best pizza around. Sit in the front room.
  • I hear that they're planning on closing, selling, changing owners, etc.
  • Order the pizza. Ashley's a great waitress!