Sutter's Mill

American, Burgers, Pub
$ $
214 Route 59
Suffern, NY 10901
11:30am - 2:00am
11:30am - 2:00am
11:30am - 2:00am
11:30am - 2:00am
11:30am - 2:00am
11:30am - 2:00am
11:30am - 2:00am


  • Everything.
  • Drinks are yummy!
  • Great food, great prices, poor service.
  • Best burgers around.
  • Play the qwikdraw!! :) dinners free if u win. ;)
  • Best French onion soup around!
  • Wing night with a side of cheesey fries...pure heaven!
  • Get the cheese fries with a side of gravy.
  • Really a very happening bar. Delicious onion soup. Shrimps and broccoli rabe also very good.
  • Friendly local people and good pub food.
  • Its a local spot but the wings are great
  • Alitas de pollo!
  • Kind of a dive, but the burgers were excellent. Could use more decent craft beer on tap
  • Amazing burger. What a great value. Ask for the fries well done!
  • I had a an order of sliders which were good. However i jad asked for well done and got 3 medium done burgers. It worked out allright cause they still tasted fresh and juicy. Place is like a Cheers set
  • Burgers, wings, apps, everything really.
  • Food and service always excellent
  • Where is my $5.00 coupon?
  • Always great food and service and a great variety of food!!
  • Yes, the wings are good! Go for them

Nearby places

250 Route 59
215 Route 59 (at S Airmont Rd)
209 Route 59