Sotto Sopra

$ $
231 Main St
Amagansett, NY 11930


  • Farfalle with Broccoli Rabe, Gorgonzola and Pine Nuts is amazing. Order it with half the oil and get some red pepper flakes. Mad house on weekend: make a reservation. Bar scene verrrry NYC.
  • Fungi pizza. Veal Milanese. Order the second you are seated or after you read this tip. Welcome to the winner's circle.
  • I am sorry, but the food blows at this place... Great atmosphere, but red sauce is 10x worse than Ragu out of the can...
  • Terrific Skirt Steak and Tasty Duck Breast!
  • The lemon drop martini, the pizza and the grilled corn!
  • The pizza, the chicken and the grilled corn are all great!
  • At pizza bar with bill. Don't forget to take a mint on the way out
  • The mints are awesome !!!!!!!
  • Whole menu is a snooze and wine list is pathetic. Branzino was great but then again who can screw that up?
  • So far, the focaccia is very fresh, gazpacho is delicious, fresh and spicy.
  • Great early bird prix fixe
  • The atmosphere here is pretty. Everything else is horrible. Focaccia is stale, calamari is cold, crab crostini is too crabby, and the clam pasta is really quite bad. I wanted to love it but no.
  • Picante Pizza!

Nearby places

161 Main St (at Amagansett Square Dr)