Shula Burger

$ $
84001 Overseas Hwy (at PCI Holiday Isle)
Islamorada, FL 33036
(305) 664-5300
11:30am - 10:00pm
11:30am - 10:00pm
11:30am - 10:00pm
11:30am - 10:00pm
11:30am - 11:00pm
11:30am - 11:00pm
11:30am - 10:00pm


  • Brand new...just opened on December 12, 2011!
  • Waited 15 minutes after being seated and didn't even get drinks. Needless to say, I don't know what the food tastes like.
  • Credit it to brand new (open 12/12/11 and my visit 12/29/11) BUT, it is pricey. Items are all sold separate. Staff does NOT work together and argues on dining room floor! Service is slow - ...
  • Horrible service! Food was pretty good, but the service was so bad, it left a bad taste in our mouth. Avoid this place, or expect bad service and you'll be fine.
  • The service here is ridiculously bad, even by Keys standards. Don Shula should be ashamed to have his name on this joint.
  • Delicious!
  • Try the French onion burger! It is awesome!!
  • Vegetarians- they sometimes have off-menu veggie burger patties that you can sub in. The wine country burger with goat cheese, red peppers is good as a veggie burger.
  • Shula burger!!
  • Decent food. Fish dip above average.
  • Really delicious burgers. My husband and son give it two thumbs up.
  • Best breakfast sandwich ever!! Egg, patty sausage, melted cheese!! Mouth watering!!
  • Worst service ever!! We had to walk out with out our food with two children. Waited over 20 minutes and barely got drinks.
  • I'll hope it was just the newness and improves as they are open but for now, you may want other tourists to work it out as the prices keep as a tourist spot and not for locals. So enjoy the vacation!
  • They pass by. Many tables empty because they don't have organized yet I hope! Slow bar with 2 bartenders for 6 at the bar! Food was good, not spectacular! You are paying to eat at Shula's only. ..
  • Staff has tables as guest arrives and sits so they work one side to the other!!! Keep this in mind and plan IF you see your waiter. Some people walk in from side door and just sit and stop staff as..
  • The fried pickles are really good. Glenn (also bartends at Pilot House) is awesome!
  • This place closed permanently. It's been replaced by an Italian restaurant, Ciao Hound.
  • Big juicy burgers! And the kids chicken tenders were fresh. So awesome! The only thing that would have made it better, would be fresh cut fries.
  • Great burgers. Not so great salads.