Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé

$ $
1292 Hertel Ave (at Crestwood Ave)
Buffalo, NY 14216
(716) 873-5730
10:30am - 9:00pm
10:30am - 9:00pm
10:30am - 9:00pm
10:30am - 10:00pm
10:30am - 10:00pm


  • I'm addicted to their sweets, the Florentine's are fantastic and cheap. Good Italian food as well but the bakery is what keeps me coming back.
  • Cassata cake!
  • Pizza is big enough for two.
  • Really good pizza and fantastic dessert.
  • The only decent pizza you'll find in Buffalo.
  • insalata mediterranea + any pizza.
  • Rembrandt: mozzarella, tomato, oil and basil on ciabatta bread. Yum!
  • The scallops were perfectly done and the pasta portions are huge! Either share a plate or be ready to take half home in a doggie bag. The tiramisu is delicious!
  • Pizza was excellent however the chicken parm lacked flavor and was cold!!
  • Love this pizza. That's all.
  • There is not one thing here that isn't amazing.
  • A great family dinner. Kid-friendly.
  • Great pizza!
  • Pizza is amazing
  • Great Pizzas
  • The stuffed red pepper is my favorite!
  • I've been frequenting R&J's since they opened when I was a young teen. They pizzas are the best original style in the city and their sandwiches are amazing.
  • Ate here once, and everything we got was between mediocre and truly awful (as in, rotting awful). It was so bad I don't think I'll ever be able to give it another shot.
  • Best pizza in Buffalo!!
  • The Juliet Salad is the best!!

Nearby places

2001 Elmwood Avenue
2626 Delaware Ave (at Hinman Ave)
1428 Hertel Ave (North Park Ave)