P&M Orange St. Market

Row 1

721 Orange St (Cottage St.)
New Haven, CT 06511
(203) 865-1147
Deli / Bodega, Italian
Mon–Sat: 7:00 AM–8:00 PM Sun: 7:00 AM–6:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • The stuffed peppers are amazing! But they don't make them everyday. I come here weekly for a Pastramy Melt Sub with grilled onions and thousand island dresing. YUM!
  • No prices on labeled products
  • Best sandwiches, salads and prepared hot foods in East Rock neighborhood. Super friendly too.
  • Get the incredible fresh-baked bread! Baguettes just like they should be: crunchy on the outside and beautifully soft in the inside.
  • Two Degrees bars are sold here! Buy a delicious food bar and give a medically formulated food pack to a hungry child. Is Good. Does Good.
  • chicken cutlet sandwich is the best
  • Everyone who works here is so nice. Best customer experience out of any local deli and grocer.
  • A small coffee is just 75 cents with any breakfast sandwich.
  • This place is always good.prefer it over both spots up and down the street.and they keep the deli open for a yummy dinner on the fly
  • delicious wraps! I would recommend this p&m over the branford location!
  • Try the seafood salad
  • Coffee and a breakfast sandwich.
  • Coffee + breakfast sandwich combo.
  • I give them all my business because they've gone out of their way to make the store handicap-accessible, and they are super accommodating. Theyll stock anything you specifically ask for.
  • Spent thirty minutes waiting for a rum and Coke here. Eventually stopped knocking on the door and went somewhere else. Frustrating.
  • Service is slow. Consistency in taste for sandwiches is almost non existent.. You might think you know what to expect when you order a sanwich, but you really never know..
  • mmmm delicious sandwiches.