Petee's Pie Company

Row 1

61 Delancey St (btwn Allen & Eldridge St)
New York, NY 10002
(212) 966-2526
Bakery, Pie Shop, Desserts
Mon–Thu: 11:00 AM–Midnight Fri: 11:00 AM–1:00 AM Sat: 10:00 AM–1:00 AM Sun: 10:00 AM–Midnight

Foursquare Tips

  • The savory chicken pie is amazing and perfect for lunch!
  • eateverypiehere
  • Lemon chess pies are great! Special pies on pi day! 3.14!!
  • Sour cherry pie with crumb top is a revelation
  • Super fresh delicious not to be missed pies. Wifey and hubby run shop. Locally sources ingredients. Gluten free options available
  • This cozy little pie shop is worthy of a dedicated visit. Grab a slice of delicious pie and a beverage of choice. I got the coconut cream pie, but will definitely be back to try the banana cream pie.
  • Skip the icebox pies. The regular ones are far more rewarding in both flavour and texture.
  • They get the crust just right. Buttery and flaky, but strong enough to hold the structure of a slice and not crumble too easily.
  • The lemon chess pie finds a beautiful balance between rich buttery composition, and the lemony zest that contrasts it.
  • Really great pies - sour cherry has a solid sweetness and great flavor. The spot is tiny, but if you can grab a seat there are a few stools along the window. They also sell bags of Parlor Coffee
  • The blueberry pie is flawless. Lemon chess was awesome too.I wish the pecan pie had a more solid nougat-y texture, but was still pretty good. Interesting ice cram favors like goat cheese, or lavender.
  • So delicious & cute little place!
  • Petee's Pie Company opens just in time for Thanksgiving. They are selling pies in flavors like maple walnut, cranberry apple, cherry crumb, and sweet potato.
  • Tried sour cherry was good
  • We tried the sour cherry pie
  • the sour cherry is bomb
  • The berry tart was nice and sour. Prices felt high ($6) for a very small slide of pie
  • Delicious!!!
  • Sesame pie is a must if you like tahini, perfectly earthy!
  • A cozy place to grab some sweet or savory pie and watch people walk by. I usually ask the staff for a recommendation on what pie to try-they all look very good and choosing is tough.