Mama Theresa's

Pizza, Italian, Wine Bar
$ $
2429 Jericho Tpke (btw Herricks Rd. & Marcus Ave.)
Garden City Park, NY 11040
(516) 747-3111



  • Grilled Chicken Parm is the best!!
  • Excellent selection of various toppings for their pizzas. Italian sandwich selection us awesome. Eat in or take out you can't go wrong here.
  • Regular slice, grandma slice, buffallo chicken slice, salad slice. Baked ziti. Chicken can not go wrong
  • The chicken marsala slice is really tasty!
  • Been coming here since 1982 still rocks!!!!!!!!
  • everything and anything is amazing.
  • As good as any slice on Long Island, which is why they can get away not delivering their pies. Aside from the regular, the sicilian and buffalo chicken are unparalleled.
  • The best house salad and bread ever.
  • Every time I come home to visit my family, I just gotta have a slice from here. Some of the best pizza on Long Island!
  • Try the buffalo pizza or chicken roll.
  • Staff is always lovely! Portions are small for lunch. Get the chicken masala pizza!
  • The buffalo chicken pizza is the thing to get here.
  • Anything is amazing, but if I had to narrow it down I would say the buffalo style chicken pizza with blue cheese....AMAZING!!!!
  • Food was very good
  • My slice was a little salty:/
  • BEST salad dressing in the World!!!!!!!!!
  • Eggplant and Pepper Panini is fantastic
  • The spinach & broccoli bocconcini is surprising light. Tasty filling. Eggplant roll was also light but filling.
  • The most AMAZING salad I've ever had. I've been going here since I was about 4...I love it!!! Sooo delicious

Nearby places

7000 Brush Hollow Road
2445 Jericho Tpke
630 Old Country Rd (btwn Clinton Rd & Meadowbrook State Pkwy)