Mama Corolla's Old Italian Restaurant

$ $
1031 E 54th St
Indianapolis, IN 46220
(317) 259-9412
5:00pm - 9:30pm
5:00pm - 9:30pm
5:00pm - 9:30pm
5:00pm - 10:00pm
5:00pm - 10:00pm



  • Watch out and make sure your entire party is present when you arrive. No call ahead seating or reservations taken. Their house policy is not to seat you until your entire party had arrived.
  • Do yourself a favor and order the crab stuffed mushroom appetizer!
  • The best Italian restaurant in this city by far. Start with the bruschetta and try the rosemary chicken lasagna.
  • The Mediterranean pasta was way better than the rosemary chicken lasagna in my opinion. Lived in Italy 5 yrs. The Italian wedding soup, and the Mediterranean chicken pasta.The crab stuffed mushroom :)
  • The good and the ambiance is fantastic
  • Cant go wrong with the garlic bread! Its to die for! Its always fun to bring a handsome man along for the ride as well!!
  • This has to be the best Italian restaurant in Indianapolis. Just make sure you get there before 630 or after 830 or you'll be waiting for awhile
  • asparagus patties and artichoke friters are fantastic appetizers.
  • Try the calamari! The sauce is magical!!!
  • You must try the Mediterranean Pasta! You will love it! Mama Carolla's is one of the best places in Indy for Date Nights.
  • Get the mussels....I don't care if you're hungry or must get them.
  • This place is phenominal. We came here just for dessert but everything here is amazing!
  • Artichoke fritters are AMAZING!
  • Ravioli was Devine! And be sure to save room for the Tiramisu.
  • Very homey American Italian with yummy fresh bread
  • Must try to the spicy meatballs!!!
  • Atmosphere food service
  • Top notch bartender & atmosphere. Server lacked in professionalism: kept my change, no wine refill-despite sitting empty until after dessert, several other minor errors, as well.
  • Very romantic setting. Affordable for a place where you can dress up! Shrimp scampi is delicious.
  • love it mamas special is it

Nearby places

5380 N College Ave (at E 54th St)
901 E 64th St (at Cornell Av)
4602 Sunset Ave (at Butler University)