Maguire's Bay Front Restaurant

Seafood, American
$ $ $
Bay Walk
Ocean Beach, NY 11770
4:00am - 10:00pm



  • Make a reservation timed for the fiery sunset on the deck. Top it with a Rocket Fuel and you can't go wrong.
  • This place sucks. Entrees are $20+, $10 salads w/ no chicken ("not enough room on the grill @ dinner") & $5 charge if an adult orders a kids item (aka, kraft mac n' cheese or 3 small chicken fingers)
  • There is a reason why we are having our wedding reception here. Good food, Bubba's 5 Rum Punch and great bay views.
  • Lobsterpalooza every Thursday.. 3 course meal for only $29.50.
  • The service was very good - the food was not. We shared our complaint with the manager - who didn't care. GO SOMEWHERE ELSE!
  • Way to expensive for what you get. The food is excellent but $150 for lunch is tooooooo much.
  • The seafood is pretty tasty and the night view of the bay is quite nice. Aim for a late dinner and avoid some of the crowd
  • Mag burger w sweet potato fries n some ice cold coronas
  • Truffle fries are food. Steak is dry and need A1 sauce to be edible.
  • Do NOT order the oysters. $29 for twelve of which four had baby crabs in them. The rest were not cleaned either...but at least no added baby crabs. GROSS. Will not be back.
  • Rocket Fuel is the cocktail to have here.
  • Best drinks on the island amd best staff!
  • Great views and best burger in Ocean Beach.
  • Couldn't be a better view.
  • No squatting
  • Go on Thursday night for the Lobsterpalooza!
  • Sunset with your dinner? This is the spot!
  • Slooooooooooooowwww service. And hard chicken. Bummer
  • Happy Hour 3-5, Monday thru Friday...$6 frozens!
  • Enjoying lobster and a wonderful sunset

Nearby places

317 Bay Walk
470 Bay Walk
Fire Island