Good Fellos Restaurant

$ $
202 W Main St
Sackets Harbor, NY 13685
(315) 646-2345



  • Wednesday Wine Night. $2 house glasses and $8 bottles. Cant beat it!
  • Excellent Brick Oven Pizza!! Goodfellos salad for two and the Capone brick oven pizza is a must!! You will not be disappointed!!!
  • Great Supreme Pizza Pie
  • The cheesecake is very satisfying
  • Service was great, friendly!
  • I'm from Brooklyn, NY where REAL brick oven pizza is created. This place is terrible for pizza and only people who don't know what great pizza is praise they're terrible mock.
  • A glass of the house wine and some brick oven pizza make for a great date night. I recommend the BBQ chicken!
  • The ravioli is good but overpriced for the serving size.
  • For quality food, service and atmosphere this is the place to go.
  • Great pizza!
  • Affordable and effective advertising visit
  • Don't hate.
  • Combat Dan has checked in two times this week without actually being at good fellows... True mayor?!!?
  • Everything here is good! The bruschetta is amazing, and the desserts are home made :)
  • For a truly unique pizza experience you gotta have the Favorite
  • Lasagna special- wow!. Mozzarella.cheddar.banana peppers.ricotta.capers.Bacon.peperoni.
  • Wonderful beer selection. Even has Smithwicks on tap.
  • Their featured and specialty dishes are great.
  • The food and service have always been great here. However, the restaurant search brings Goodfellos up for vegan menu. It does not have vegan / plant based options.

Nearby places

214.5 W. Main St (General Smith Dr)
110 W Main St