Gelateria @ Eataly

Row 1

200 5th Ave (at W 23rd St)
New York, NY 10010
(212) 229-2560
Ice Cream, Desserts
Mon–Sun: 11:00 AM–11:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Try the salted caramel & hazelnut gelato!
  • Best salted caramel and sweet milk gelato in NYC
  • Iced Frangelico Cappuccino is lighter than air. It doesn't make you feel so bad for eating a scoop of gelato immediately afterwards.
  • The caramel is CRAZY caramel strong. Not a bad thing...
  • Taste it all
  • Salted Caramel aka heaven
  • Have the nocciola and cioccolato it's an amazing combination.
  • Scrumptious gelato made fresh daily. Make sure to sample the specials. Expect a 5-10 min line around lunchtime.
  • Try the Calamari pasta which has Fresh scallops and shrimp ! Delicious!! I have to say the portion is a bit small !!
  • Love their pistachio gelato. Its brownish color shows it's made with real nuts, not just flavored like its green-colored imitations.
  • The pistachio gelato was smooth, creamy, filling, and extremely refreshing on a hot NYC day
  • Try the ciocolatto and caramello al sale, both delicious.
  • Delicioso!!!!
  • Double Cup of Salted Caramel. Do not pass Go. Do not collect $200. Do. Not. Miss. Trying. This.
  • Hazelnut gelato is retarded good
  • Nocciola gelato yummy!
  • Extremely creamy and yummy gelato.
  • Delicious ice cream!! Tiramis the best ice cream I've ever eaten! perfect combination with Belgian chocolate! Loved!
  • Cross contamination is going on here, so not a good place for people with nut allergies.
  • The affogato is a true delight.