DiCarlo's Pizza

1311 Main St (btwn 12th & 13th)
Wheeling, WV 26003
(304) 233-0730



  • The unique combination of Hot Crust and Cold Cheese and the favorite pizza of home town country singer Brad Paisley and others.
  • Get the extra cheese in a bag. You won't be dissappointed!
  • DiCarlo's Pizza is THE gastronomical pizza mecca for the City of Wheeling and a MUST for anyone visiting the area
  • I've eaten at eight different Dicarlos locations and I'd have to say that Elm Grove ranks #1 and the downtown Wheeling location ranks around #5. I'm not trying to be biased, just honest.
  • I think some people may be confusing the Dicarlos in downtown Wheeling with the one in Elm Grove. The downtown location is ok, but it doesn't come close to Elm Grove.
  • Mmmm good
  • The calzones are excellent!
  • Gotta get it and eat it right there in the store or in your car, where ever you can get to it the fastest lol. If you have to wait till you get home, definitely gotta get extra cheese in a bag
  • DiCarlo's is a Wheeling staple. If you've never been here, it should be next on your list.
  • Best pizza ever! Ate here a lot during vacation & it's the best pizza I have ever tasted
  • Absolutely amazing food. We ate here twice in one day
  • If this isn't on your list, I can't help you
  • This is a nice place 2 get pizza in Wheeling.
  • Best of all DiCarlo's. Dont know why teletech is putting ads up though. Eat there its much better right out of the oven.
  • Best pizza

Nearby places

2 14th St (at South St)
1400 Main St (14th St.)