Castaway Restaurant

American, Bar
$ $ $ $
1406 Oceanview Ave
Marathon, FL 33050
(305) 743-6247



  • Honey buns are great. Good food & service.
  • I love sushi - and the surf and turf roll might honestly be one of my favs...
  • Our first time, I thought the food was good and the staff friendly. Loved the Buffalo Shrimp appetizers.
  • Food was mid grade at best. I did not have their sushi, however, watched a server leave fresh sushi in the window for over 30 min. Not my idea of fresh. will not be going back. Expected more for $200
  • The beer sampler is great, especially if you are having trouble deciding.
  • Sushi is good and fresh
  • Try the conch burger! It's a baaad (very good) burger!
  • The Castaway burger will NOT dissapoint.
  • Unassuming fish shack, but great food. Big menu. Solid bar. Patio and music.
  • Chicken parm awesome
  • Server was obviously new but very sweet. Food was very generous portions but just ok
  • 52 beers on tap & $3 breakfasts mimosas
  • Try the Spicy Tuna Hot Dog or the Shrimp Rueben.
  • Tuna in radish "tacos" are excellent. The wahoo nigiri is also incredible.
  • Sushi. The food and drinks are always great.
  • Our second time this week before our departure and it was amazing once again! This time had Mahi stuffed w/ shrimp & scallops!
  • Mahi stuffed with crab with lobster sauce was amazing! Melissa was an AMAZING server. She went over the top to make us feel comfortable.
  • Got the snapper mazatlan!!! BOOM. Taste o the Island winner. Outstanding job castaway, great music too!
  • Great food with a large variety of choices. Love the two year sushi roll.
  • Lovely spot. Giant menu with lots of adventurous options. Hugely friendly staff.

Nearby places

7 Knights Key Blvd (at Mile Marker 47)
4555 Overseas Hwy
61 Hawks Cay Blvd (near US 1)