Papa's Tomato Pies

19 Robbinsville Allentown Road
Robbinsville, NJ 08691
(609) 208-0006
11:00am - 9:30pm
11:00am - 9:30pm
11:00am - 9:30pm
11:00am - 9:30pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 9:00am


  • The oldest continuously running pizzeria in America is also one of the tastiest. I loved the plain pie here. Getting one with onions, shrooms, and garlic detracts from the homemade sauce's flavor.
  • The tomato pies real good and the mustard pie is good if you like mustard. Good service
  • Mustard pie FTW!
  • First time here and it was great! Great food cheap!
  • Tomatoe pie plain heaven deliciousness! Stuffed artichoke also great! Super nice people! Well be back for more!
  • More than just tomato pies
  • PIZZA PIE :-) Molto Bene!
  • Great mustard pie!
  • A national treasure. One of the best pies (if not the best) you'll find...period. Sausage is my personal favorite, but I hear great things about the famous mustard pie.
  • The oldest continuously run, family pizza place
  • Try the mustard pie, sounds weird but is really good! Sausage pie is also awesome, in both "regular" form or as a mustard pie.
  • Bring your own beer or wine!
  • Great pies
  • Great tomato pie!
  • Great mustard pies
  • For the meatball lovers, try the ones here with your pasta. Soft and juicy!
  • Great Tomato Pies, Trenton area ICON.. Great Prices
  • The best tomato pies in the area!! New location, check it out.
  • Tomotoe pie and mustard pie are both good. Mustard pie just has a little tangy test. Great window pickup for covid times
  • Highly recommend trying the mustard pie with sausage and pepperoni! My favorite!!

Nearby places

4617 Nottingham Way (RT 33)
19 Robbinsville Allentown Rd