Nica's Market

Deli / Bodega, Gourmet
$ $
603 Orange St (Humphrey St.)
New Haven, CT 06511
(203) 787-5919
7:00am - 7:00pm
7:00am - 7:00pm
7:00am - 7:00pm
7:00am - 7:00pm
7:00am - 7:00pm
7:00am - 7:00pm
7:00am - 4:00pm



  • if you bring your own thermos your coffee is only a dollar! their flag and southwest Paninis are my favorite!
  • "Only amateurs stick to the menu?" Like my taint. Eat what you want to eat. Literally everything is good here.
  • Eat everything.
  • He classic panini is amazeballs!
  • This place has like everything! Awesome food.
  • Great sandwiches but gets crowded at lunch time. Be patient though cause the line moves fast.
  • Breakfast sandwiches are made to order, so it'll take a couple extra minutes but they're so worth it!
  • Try the Flag with prosciutto or the thanksgiving (seasonal) and the desserts are amazing.
  • Try the Flag panini with pepperoni!
  • Flag panini + pepperoni = epic win
  • Always check the daily hot and cold dishes! Only amateurs stick to the menu
  • There are three markets on orange St all in close vicinity - this one is my favorite.
  • Good breakfast sandwiches. Also, any sandwich will feed you for a day.
  • The flag sandwich is awesome!
  • Deli sandwiches of all types to die for!!!
  • Less expensive than Romeos and higher quality than P&M. I love this place! All the sandwiches are good and the cinnamon buns and muffins are awesome too.
  • Love the food
  • Classic on Rustico bread is the way to go
  • Try the L'alpino - Great bread + fresh and tasty ingredients = delicious panino!!
  • The food in the back is cold!!!

Nearby places

41 Cold Spring St
721 Orange St (Cottage St.)
1080 State St