Mullens Dairy and Eatery

Ice Cream, American
212 W Main St
Watertown, WI 53094
(920) 261-4278



  • Malts are incredible, but then again, anything made with their ice cream is!
  • Their food is amazing.
  • Chocolate malt is the best!
  • Best Reuben I've ever had...
  • Best turtle sundae ever!!!
  • Best ice cream ever!!! Same place as it was in the 50's.
  • The Black & White with Spanish Peanuts... Always the winner!
  • Ice cream
  • Sunday afternoon service was awful. Kids working had two tables to wait on and let the line waiting for carryout ice cream sit while they chatted for many minutes. Group of 4 left behind us.
  • Awesome place for real ice cream sundaes, floats and shakes. Amazing and very reasonable.
  • The Malt's are great.