Maffei's Pizza

Row 1

688 Avenue of the Americas (W 22nd St)
New York, NY 10010
(212) 929-0949

Foursquare Tips

  • Go to Maffei's and get the grandma slice.
  • The special is unbeatable! 2 cheese slices and a can/fountain drink! Yum
  • The grandma slice is a good standby, but the neapolitan is even better.
  • 2 slices and a 16oz drink for 5bucks? Can't go wrong!
  • Tourists - do not waste your $ at Olive Garden or Chipotle! Enjoy these great slices of NYC (at a fraction of the cost) instead! Bonus: super friendly owners
  • Get yourself either the buffalo chicken slice (have 'em put bleu cheese on it!) or get the shrimp parmigiana hero. They also do an awesome bacon, egg, and cheese on a hero for breakfast.
  • Grandma Slice!
  • New and improved!
  • Dominic is the best! If you are ordering a Grandma's pie, ask for the 'imported' ingredients. It's much better.
  • My go-to place for real NY style pizza. No bad tasting pies here!
  • I had my first ever slice of pizza here and have been a regular customer ever since.
  • The staff is great and owner is always happy to help. The food is great.
  • Dom and company are all nice people.
  • 2 Slices and a soda. 5 bucks. Boom.
  • Grandma slice all the way! I ask the guys to leave it in the oven for a bit so it gets nice n crispy! :-)
  • Grandma's pie and shrimp parm heros are my favorites
  • Great lunch at a great price. Pizza, hot plates, anything...
  • unreal lunch bargain, ie: chicken parm over pasta, comes w/bread, $7.50 and it will last d-a-y-s. their pasta choices way go beyond spaghetti in red sauce
  • Best pizza in the neighborhood (that's the word of an Italian American Brooklynite). AM breakfast special: bacon, egg & cheese sandwich & coffee $4.
  • Breakfast special cant be beat.