Kat & Theo

New American
$ $ $ $
5 W 21st St New York (b/t Avenue Of The Americas & 5th Ave)
New York, NY 10010
(212) 380-1950



  • The place is dimly lit and great for romantic dates!!! Wine and cocktail list has amazing options... food menu was limited and unique, but amazing choices overall
  • Everything was wonderful! Beautiful wooden interior, great wine selection, impeccable service, outstanding presentation & creative use of ingredients. Juan and Chris Lee were perfect! Coming back!
  • Bread and (duck fat) butter is a KILLER bar snack. Yum.
  • They have this 2 amazing drinks that I don't remember the name but you can see them in the picture, they are just amazing!!! And the bartender is super cool!! Great service.
  • drop in just for a cocktail
  • very delicate food and the atmosphere and service are great for date! a lot of veggie options too.
  • Try the Rodger Dodger, very yummy, made by excellent bartenders Cheung or Chris!
  • Come to eat or drink -- great cocktails
  • Have been here many times - always great. Wonderful service, great atmosphere and food is excellent. Try the new brunch - Eggs Benedict FANTASTIC
  • Nice atmosphere for cocktails, but I'd skip it for dinner. Trying too hard to be fancy on presentation, and too expensive for what you get.
  • New menu, much better than it is rated here.
  • Some unique Mediterranean accents: a sweet onion soubric with steak (Morocco), also chicken soup with trahanas (Greece).
  • Pass. Service was excellent but the food was mediocre at best
  • Super cute date spot w an evolving seasonal menu, brought to you by alums from Per Se and Eleven Madison. Octopus was my fav hands down & the dessert is not to be missed!
  • Romantic, quiet and delicate restaurant. Loved EVERYTHING that we ordered. For the appetizer, carpaccio, charred octopus, lobster with grapefruit. Liked steak more than porcelet. Good desserts
  • Octopus is great. So is the pork loin and duck.
  • Avoid for now at least. Mediocre food with really poor service. Hope things get better.
  • Great presentation and lovely favors. Loved the scallops and the skate.
  • Very pleasant date night decor, superb and original cocktails, good food, fun desserts.
  • Avoid. Terrible service. Mediocre food. Would never go back.