Island Mermaid

Bar, Seafood
$ $
780 Bay Walk
Ocean Beach, NY 11770
(631) 583-8088


  • Best bartendahs... Ask Phil for a spidah
  • Hailey is the best the mermaid has ever had! She is smart, cheerful, and never gets an order wrong! We never ask for anyone else.
  • Ask for Hailey - she's super cute, friendly and best service ever!
  • The peanut butter & jelly wrap is AWESOME!!! Lobster rolls are great, too. Delish food & great drinks.
  • Double Rocket Fuel is the way to go
  • Ask for joe behind the bar, he makes a great Sagatiba caipirinha! Delicious!
  • Ask for Phil at the bar he makes best rocket fuels and mudslides and awesome service
  • VERY slow service. I cannot believe it.
  • Warning: Bartenders suck..slow..inattentive
  • Dry, over cooked food, overpriced, and the man seating guests is very rude. Better choices on the Island.
  • This place is super busy and popular among the island visitors. Make sure you call and make reservations well in advance. Good food, next to the water!
  • A bit pricey, but great views and after dark club life. Also wish they would offer a vegan option
  • Don't come hungry!! Long wait for food!!!!
  • Make a reservation for dinner. Don't you dare try to reserve my grandparent's corner table.
  • Just hope the staff isn't hungover.
  • Food is good and reasonable
  • Chef Joe is the head chef... He's the best! Try anything! It's all good!!!!
  • Weekend at Bernie's. Icy sugary drinks in plastic cups. Nothing artisanal. Totally appropriate.
  • Ask for manwel as a waiter
  • Chocolate martinis are the BEST!

Nearby places

781 Evergreen Walk
470 Bay Walk