Gotham Pizza

Row 1

144 9th Ave (at 19th Street)
New York, NY 10011
(212) 989-8858
Mon–Thu, Sat–Sun: 11:00 AM–11:30 PM Fri: 11:00 AM–Midnight

Foursquare Tips

  • The pizza at Gotham Pizza is by no means greata little greasy, the sauce is a little heavy-handed with dried herbs. What is great about it is the crustrolled in a heavy coating of bread crumbs.
  • Great lunch special: 2 GIANT slices of regular pizza and a soda for $5 even. Hard to top that in New York.
  • Gave pizza place to order delivery from. The margarita slice (or whole pie) is really the bee's knees.
  • +1 on the slice of grandma. Amazing
  • A middle-of-the-road NY-style slice that's set apart by its unique breadcrumb coated crust.
  • This is the best "grandma pie" in Manhattan.
  • The crust is awesome, real crunchy. I really like this thin pizza.
  • Pizza with a little different take on their crust. Not bad.
  • My slice place. Thin crust pies, and a solid Grandma slice if you want something more hearty.
  • The Margherita is my favorite slice
  • Better than Stella's pizza. My favorite around Chelsea.
  • Sooo delicious!!
  • The Margarita pizza is really good.
  • Crust is amazing, could eat everyday!
  • +1 on crust and the special. Though the pizza place up the block has the same deal.
  • I love Buffalo Chicken pizza and White Pizza, both are amazing...
  • Standard Manhattan pizza joint. There is better out there but it's good.
  • Great margarita pizza, fresh mozzarella with rich tomato sauce and basil. Really recommend!
  • Pizza slices flavorful. Use corn meal in the crust for some extra crunch.
  • Best pizza in the neighborhood for delivery > Patsy's (now closed) >> Famous Ray's. Crunchy crust & fresh ingredients. Order delivery all the time.