Gotham Pizza

1443 York Ave (btw 76th & 77th)
New York, NY 10075
(212) 288-8085


  • best pizza on the UES
  • Haven't found better pizza in the city than this really, the crust is nice and crispy, scrumptious.
  • There regular cheese slice is absolutely great.
  • Meatballs are so good & they use fresh veggies
  • Margarita slice, yummy..
  • Grandma slice and margarita slice r to die for!!!
  • Crispy pizza crust. Plain and pizza Slices to go plus fresh vegetables and mushroom slices made to order.
  • Best plain slice in the nearby area. If you can swing a whole pie, the grandmas with sausage is awesome.
  • Decent local pizza place, but it's pricy and a little garlicky. Grandma slice is pretty good. Good if you want a fast slice in the area.
  • Thin crust pizza and garlic knots
  • Fantastic Grandma's slice.
  • Yummy pizza
  • Their grandma pizza is one of my fav slices in the city
  • Grandma pizza is the best at this joint
  • Thanks to you, business knows what not to do! Most despicable customer service. Even though it WAS restaurant's fault. Wait, my bad, restaurant? No, hole in the wall. Ew
  • Margarita Great crust - thin & crunchy
  • Best pizza in NYC (seriously)
  • Grandma slice is da bomb!
  • Get a grandma and a Margherita. They are both excellent.
  • Best lunch deal in the city. 2 slices and a drink for $5

Nearby places

2 Cherokee Pl (btwn E 76th & E 77th St)
1439 York Ave
1443 York Ave (at E 77th St)