Gotham Bagels

Bagels, Coffee Shop
112 E Mifflin St (at N Pickney St.)
Madison, WI 53703
(608) 467-7642
7:00am - 3:00pm
7:00am - 3:00pm
7:00am - 3:00pm
7:00am - 3:00pm
7:00am - 3:00pm
7:00am - 3:00pm
8:00am - 2:00pm


  • Genuine (and excellent) New York bagels. The owner knows how to make them because he's from Long Island, arguably home to some of the best bagels in the country.
  • Pineapple mint juice is fantastic!
  • Great fresh bagels. Had wild mushroom and parmagiano cream cheese. Yummmm!
  • Just about as good as Terrace Bagel in Brooklyn, but a lot friendlier. Try the super egg everything with scallion spread and lox, or just with olive spread.
  • Egg bagel plus scallion cream cheese is a little slice of heaven
  • Everything is good. Owners are from Long Island-bagels taste like ny bagels and place feels like a ny bagel shop. Just like home!
  • Salt bagels plus olive cream cheese are bestest!! :)
  • Get an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox. It's phenomenal.
  • I love the pastrami & egg; add their fresh mozzarella!
  • Weird that this place does not have an 8+ rating. Amazing hand rolled bagels, great lunch menu, stylish interior, what else do you need? Try their sausage & egg bagel, it's fantastic.
  • Bagels are tasty. Cream cheese is not up to NYC standards
  • You don't come here for the service. You come here for the amazing bagels. I always get the yellow cab on an onion and then scallion cream cheese on an everything
  • WiFi password: batman16
  • Best Bagels in Madison very close to What you get in NYC or Long Island. They even have bialys and cel-ray! Lox is a great deal!
  • Chunky vegetable cream cheese
  • Closest thing you'll find to a NYC bagel outside of NYC.
  • The egg with avacado and cheese
  • Lox is overly salty, and the bagels aren't as risen as the traditional nyc ones.
  • It's easy to fall into a regular order at Gotham, but try experimenting. They mix it up with new specials, even getting fresh seafood 24-hr fresh from Montauk.
  • don't order sausage if you want actual sausage! They give you essentially a hamburger patty

Nearby places

Capitol Square (at Mifflin, Main, Carroll, Pinckney)
127 N Hamilton St (at N Webster St)
25 S Pinckney St