Four54 Grill

Row 1

454 New Holland Ave (Plum St)
Lancaster, PA 17602
(717) 390-2626
$ $
Mon: 11:00 AM–3:00 PM Tue–Wed: 11:00 AM–7:00 PM Thu–Fri: 11:00 AM–8:00 PM Sat: Noon–8:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • You can't beat the chicken ceaser salad.
  • Menu on this site is 2 years old, needs to be updated. Food is still spectacular though!!!
  • Great Burgers!!!! Pizza is awesome The fresh ingredients and never frozen meats are perfectly seasoned and cooked to order. Interesting flavor and texture combinations!!!
  • The pizza special for $3.98 makes for a very cost-effective and delicious lunch. Includes tiny soft-drink.
  • Everything
  • Burgers cheesesteak fries
  • Today I ordered a sandwich and realized that the chicken was raw. The manger was not sympathetic at all and gave me some free coleslaw and attitude when I inquired about a coupon for my next visit.
  • Pizza, blackened salmon, cheese steak, and mile high ham and cheese sandwiches. Oh, duh...fresh mozzarella sticks!!! Heaven!
  • Plenty of parking beyond the six attached spaces... Lot across street (marked as Science Factory) is ours too!
  • Burgers are on par with Shake Shack (meaning, pretty damn good). If you're in the mood for something other than burgers, order the beer battered fish sandwich. It's sublime!
  • The Pulled Pork was awesome!
  • If you were here under the previous owners, give Four54 a try. The food is much better. Fresh, not frozen, including fresh-cut fries!
  • New owner. Food is amazing. Loaded cheese fries are best anywhere and southwest chicken sandwich is the bomb.
  • Nick's Moms food is the Best EVER!!
  • Right down the the wraps and salads for an affordable, quick lunch.
  • They have amazing burgers, many levels above others in the area.