Domenick & Pia Downtown Pizzeria

Row 1

Details
3 Brook St
Waterbury, CT 06702
(203) 753-3401
Map

Every year, hundreds of well-known places are considered in pursuit of the 101 Best Pizzas in America, and locals across America cry foul about pit-stops along the pizza-writer trail getting attention when their local pizzeria is “10 times better” (usually followed by “You don’t know what you’re talking about”). In the case of Domenick and Pia DeRosa’s eponymous spot in Waterbury, they may have a point.

Like another famous Dom about 100 miles south (Dom DeMarco of Brooklyn's Di FaraNo. 2) Domenick and his wife Pia have been making pies their way for a long time. Just three years after marrying in Italy in 1961, they decided to open a pie shop that sold by the slice like New York City pizzerias did, an idea their landlord and carpenter scoffed at. They’ve moved once over the years, but otherwise they’ve proved everyone wrong, using the same mixer, ovens, and recipes all this time.

“It’s a sweet sauce,” the nonagenarian pizzaiolo said in a video last year. Domenick still comes in from time to time to help, although he doesn’t do very much heavy lifting anymore. But his tradition lives on in the pies they make every day.

These are old-school Neapolitan pizzas: super-thin undercarriage and an old-school crunchy cornicione — no doughy chew. There are no fancy toppings here — try the pepperoni — just an approach to pizza that mirrors the couple’s philosophy on how to have a good marriage: adherence to moral values. “We made a vow before God to stick together in sickness and in health,” Domenick explained. And in pizza.

— Arthur Bovino, 101 Best Pizzas in America 2015, 8/6/2015

Foursquare Tips

  • Best original pizza ever! In waterbury! $1.25 a slice $10.00 a large!
  • Pizza. Good. Cash only.
  • absolute best pizza in Waterbury- HANDS DOWN!
  • Best pizza around!
  • Smile at Pia, she's a sweet lady!
  • BEST Pizza in CT without a doubt
  • Try a slice of cheese with some garlic powder, grated cheese and a little crushed red pepper...mmmmmm!
  • Incredible pizza. Best I've had in CT
  • Good pizza and decent price. Friendly staff as well
  • There pizza and their subs
  • This us the best pizza in watebury ct
  • I've had pizza in the 4 cities considered to house the best pizza places. Brooklyn N.Y, Chicago, New Haven CT and Naples Italy and Domenic and Pia fits right in with the best of them. Great sauce!