Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream
509 Main St (Montauk Hwy) (@ Union Ave)
Islip, NY 11751
- Go here and enjoy old-time sweet shop favorites and the freshest ice cream in the Great South Bay area.
- Cannoli milk shake
- I can't even recommend an ice cream to try--they are all THAT GOOD. If you are nearby, you must come to Coyle's!
- MONSTER MASH. MONSTER. MOTHEEFLIPPIN'. MASH.
- The mint chocolate chip is the best. You can tell It's made on site & fresh. Better than Friendly's. Look in pennysaver for coupons during summer.
- The pistachio cherry is insanely good.