Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe

Row 1

Smith Street (Midway Road)
Shelter Island, NY 11965
(631) 749-1851

Foursquare Tips

  • Good lunch option and lobster rolls!
  • Buy live lobsters, take them home & race them.
  • Southern soul style type fried fish. It's not to be missed when you are visiting shelter Island. There is also an outdoor dining area I reccomend during warmer weather.
  • Don't miss their Sunday brunch! Amanda makes an amazing meal from chicken and waffles, salmon, challah French toast and Gouda frittata and shrimp grits! Amazing!!
  • cole slaw ---> food poisoning
  • 30-45 minute wait is worth it. Smoked tuna appetizer, soft-shell crabs, fried shrimp. BYOB if you'd like a beer. Has a bit of a Nawlins vibe.
  • Fried chicken is great. Ribs as well. Smoked fish too.