Brother's BBQ

Row 1

2402 Route 32
New Windsor, NY 12550
(845) 534-4226

Foursquare Tips

  • Open Tuesday thru Thursday 11am - 930pm and Friday & Saturday 11am - 1030 pm Sunday noon - 9pm phone number is 845 534-4bbq (4226)
  • Hands down best place to get some TASTY food in the New Windsor/Cornwall area. You can't go wrong with anything you order. It is all delicious!! AND you're supporting a local business!
  • So in love with this place!!!!! Great food great establishment owners are the nicest people ever!!!!!!
  • Brisket!!!!
  • Good food very filling.. the mixed drinks are awesome they def don't skimp on the alcohol.
  • Awesome food, ribs were slamming..
  • Know that you can get two meals out of any one plate of meat(s).
  • So happy to have them back, absolutely delicious
  • Back in biz after the fire!!! Everything is AWESOME!!!!
  • Definitely try the uncle Dave!! It's a sampler and it is AMAZING!!! Perfect to split btw 2 people!!! can't wait to come back!!!
  • Love the BBQ sauce on ANYTHING
  • First time visiting, I had the Stuff Burger, chose american cheese and added bacon. Man was this things good. Inserting cheese into the middle of the burger and on top, oozing cheese with each bite!
  • Excellent NC BBQ!! Definitely worth the trip!
  • Good smoked meat--$5 charge to share a meal
  • Everything is amazing!!! Best BBQ!! Service always good and live music!!!
  • Unique food items, and if you love BBQ then this is the place to go. A bit on the pricey side. They do pick up ordering.
  • Horrible experience ordered half rack of ribs and a pulled pork sandwich with wings they ran out of baby bay switched to st Louise they ran out of those after waiting 45 more min canceled order n left
  • Beans were overly sweet. Brisket lacked smoke ring. Disappointed.
  • Food was good, waitress was horrible.
  • The Uncle Dave with the cole slaw and candied yams is a GREAT date dish!