Brewsters Seafood Market

Row 1

252 E Montauk Hwy (canoe place road)
Hampton Bays, NY 11946
(631) 728-3474

Foursquare Tips

  • Great food, the lobster special is amazing and the shrimps are very fresh. The service is friendly but takes awhile. The stuff fish is the best and a must try dish!
  • Fresh mako was only $10.50 a lb.
  • All of their smoked fish is wonderful, but you MUST pick up some smoked swordfish. It is to die for. Pick up some scallops to cook up, as well. They're really fresh!
  • The place is called "Out of the Blue" now and it's more of a market than a restaurant.
  • Lobster roll is all lobster. Good fish & chips
  • The lobster bisque rocks! Got a $5 off from checking in at foursquare, amazing!
  • ... and good prices.
  • Very good, fresh seafood market. Friendly service.
  • Super fresh seafood. Loved my fish tacos.
  • Go to for deal on lobster dinner .
  • Go to restaurant .com and you can get deals for this place .
  • simple as can be. If you're looking for some fresh steamers and local oysters it's a great spot.
  • Try the Manhattan Clam Chowder!
  • Try the Softshell Crab Sandwich - Great sandwich. Not too fried, still #juicy. #Fresh bun and #yummy fries. Plus, got $5 off for signing in through Foursquare.
  • The lobster roll. Don't ask questions, just do it.
  • Try the smoked salmon.
  • steamer buckets look great!