Row 1

1359 Hoban St
Mackinac Island, MI 49757
(906) 847-0260

Foursquare Tips

  • Come with an empty stomach! Portions are huge and delicious!
  • easily the best place to get food and beer on the island.
  • Full full full full nice
  • Calamari is an awesome appetizer
  • They only have Pepsi products, no Coke :(
  • OMG there are hooks under the bar for your purse/coat/shopping bags. Best idea ever!
  • Fish and chips are wonderful! Service is great too.
  • We weren't treated very well here. Server was not attentive at all. We do however love the chicken gnocchi.
  • Wife and I ordered a pizza and very hot and cheesy. Burned the roof of my mouth because I couldn't wait to eat it. Defiantly need to wait to cook before eating.
  • Prime rib sliders 7/10 (real good with the horseradish sauce, a little fatty), butternut squash was good 7/10, scallops were decent 8/10, the bread dipping oil was really good (has parmesan in it).
  • Locals sit @ the bar. Good people, great stories. Good food!
  • Pepsi products. One of the few on the island. Thumbs up.
  • Bad food, bad service. Eat chocolate fudge instead.
  • Best French fries on the island!
  • Expensive but good.
  • Niki is the best bartender!
  • The first night we ate @ Goodfellow's the food and service were fantastic! We went back the next afternoon and the service was aweful!!! The food was still good though.
  • If you are a fan of Lobster or Alaskan King Crab then this is the place. Been here three times and I've never been dissapointed.
  • Shots come in a chilled rocks glass! Nice!
  • Nikki at the bar will always give good service. :) That woman is everywhere!