Croton Reservoir Tavern

Bar, American, Music Venue
$ $ $
108 W 40th St (at 6th Ave)
New York, NY 10018
(212) 997-6835
11:30am - 9:00pm
11:30am - 9:00pm
11:30am - 9:00pm
11:30am - 9:00pm
11:30am - 9:00pm



  • Great Happy Hour
  • The downstairs is usually less crowded. Also, be sure totake advantage of happy hour!
  • Awesome selection of whiskey! :)
  • Brunch every Saturday! Unlimited Mimosas, Bellinies and Bloody Marys! Think no further!
  • Get ready for croton brunches starting in feburary keep watching and following me for details or like crotonnyc on facebook, twitter,and four square.
  • If you're there for a lunch meeting, ask to be seated downstairs. It's quieter and there's wi-fi.
  • Great donw stairs happy hour. 80's baby.
  • Try the Guinness Draught
  • Looking for somewhere decent to pre-game before going to an event @ MSG? Look no further. Happy hour M-F, 5-9pm downstairs.
  • Nice bar with booth seating as well. Decent beer selection on tap and a full wall of liquor choices. Plenty of TVs playing the local NY games. Food looked good. (3 of 4 petals via Fondu)
  • Great happy hour specials on food and drink from 5-9pm! But only downstairs and only if they don't have a private event going on...
  • Loved it. Came for 9-11 10yr reunion. Service was great. Awesome conversation with GM Chad.
  • Don't miss our Annual Guilty Pleasures Party - Sat 4/2 (8pm-2am)DJ + Cover Band playing all the songs you hate... to admit you love :)FREE shot to 1st 100 people & FREE Candy.. to help ease the guil
  • The Mac and cheese is great, has a slight kick to it due to the pepper jack cheese.
  • Interesting seating policy. If you're a person of color, I bet they won't seat you on the elevated platform. Food wasn't worth the $ at all. I won't be back.
  • Good bar and very good food
  • Decent spot for after work drinks. They have a casual downstairs room with tables and room to stand by the bar.
  • Across the street from Bryant Park, so the happy hour crowd was very typical midtown bro-y... nothing special in the standard happy hour (from what I remember)
  • Great atmosphere and great drinks! Great spot for a happy hour.
  • Happy hour isapparentlyonly valid downstairs. But the bar down there is nice and secret.

Nearby places

E 42nd St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave)
Broadway & 7th Ave (btwn W 42nd & 47th St)
123 W 39th St (btw 6th Ave and Broadway)