The Black Sheep

$ $
583 3rd Ave (btwn 38th & 39th)
New York, NY 10016
(212) 599-3476



  • Had cockroach landed on me. Lovely, not!
  • typical pub, less douchy than most midtown east pubs
  • Please do not let your friends know that you add salt to your beer.....
  • Three of us had a corned beef sandwich. It was dry and unseasoned. None of us would recommend it.
  • Liked it, tasty food, fun company, best for sport-evening or a lunch
  • Good lunch specials and Jameson on tap. Lol what more is there to say.
  • Awesome music (70s-90s) and a relaxed, non-douchey, not too loud setting. Lots of TVs for sports too!
  • Take care of Sean
  • Why does the grey goose taste like banana runts?
  • Let's go GIANTS
  • Can be loud sometimes. Make friends with the bartender. Otherwise, small mediocre Irish pub.
  • Shepards pie is solid. Huge portion.
  • beats the hell out of going to almost any other Third Ave pub
  • Great to place for a pint
  • Typical Irish bar in Midtown. But they have a chicken pot pie that I've never experienced anywhere else. And I'm a chicken pot-pie elitist.
  • Good value at happy hour
  • Get the chicken pot pie and order it "juicy." You'll be coming back for it again and again. It's amazing.
  • Scary. Very scary.
  • Loved the music (6/21)!!!
  • Ask for a free drink if you guess the price of the pennies in the bar (Spoiler Alert)--- $180

Nearby places

560 3rd Ave (at E 37th St)
329 Lexington Ave (btwn 38th & 39th St.)
160 E 38th St (btwn Lexington & 3rd Ave)