- Best tuna melt in the world!
- tuna melt is heaven!
- Bowl of Oyster Soup, Tuna Melt, Cold Beer.
- Don't be a retard. Get the tuna melt.
- The peanut butter pie is amazing.
- No cellphones allowed, ya summer idiot. You better be reading this from the parking lot or further.
- Amazing fresh tuna salad!!
- The greatest bar of all time.
- Get the mussels (best ever!) and a bowl of the chili! Great filling meal!!!
- The tuna melt is literally to die for
- Best mussels hands down and fantastic vegetarian sandwich!
- Best mussels in the Hamptons. (Lotsa garlic!)
- the nachos are a meal all by themselves
- Ask for multiple modifications to the menu and then ask George to tell you a story.
- The fries were incredible
- Good local bar with a better than expected food menu.
- Fresh seafood chill intimate dining off the grid
- The only decent bar / restaurant left in Montauk.
- Try the softshell crab sandwich it's great. You'll never get bored looking at the jokes and retro, vintage, or quirky stuff on the walls. They even have the Montauk monster!
- Try the softshell crab sandwich. It's awesome.