South Brooklyn Pizza

122 1st Ave
New York NY 10009
(212) 533-2879
Categories Food

Unfortunately, this venue is now closed.

South Brooklyn Pizza Photos
  1. South Brooklyn Pizza
  2. South Brooklyn Pizza
  3. South Brooklyn Pizza
  4. South Brooklyn Pizza
  5. South Brooklyn Pizza
  6. South Brooklyn Pizza

The Daily Meal Editors and Community Say
Arthur Bovinotdm-35-icon.png

Arthur Bovino, Editor

South Brooklyn Slice, East Village Style. Quick, who makes New York City's best slice? Joe's on Carmine in Greenwich Village? DiFara in Midwood, Brooklyn, at $5 per slice? It's a tricky question. Everybody in New York City swears by their place, and well, most of them don't... Read More

Add Your Review

Around the Web
South Brooklyn Pizza: News & Coverage on New York Magazine
Recent news and coverage of South Brooklyn Pizza.
South Brooklyn Pizza - Carroll Gardens - New York Magazine Restaurant Guide
These pizza shacks do one thing–and do it very well; churn out pizzas with tasty char. See the review of this Pizza restaurant at 451 Court St. in Brooklyn.
South Brooklyn Pizza - Toby's Public House - Roberta's -- New York Magazine Underground Gourmet Revi
Three quirky new joints attempt to redefine the Brooklyn pie-eating experience.
Foursquare Tips
Gabriel Colby
Some of the absolute best pizza in town. Yes, I said that. Some of the best pizza in all of NYC
Cody Robbins
Get the pizza.
Village Voice
While plenty of neighborhood restaurants are making tiny, expensive, artisan pies, this little stall makes a far superior version. Read: extra oil, extra herbs, and shockingly good tomato sauce.
Sajid Mehmood
Look down at the slice you just ordered. Does it have 4 corners? If so, you're doing it wrong.
Eden Sutley
Best pizza in the world. Seriously.
Lilach Feldman
Amie Romano
Now that is pizza! Freshest ingredients and amazing staff. Ask for extra parmigiana! Molto bene!
Sajid Mehmood
You want the standard margherita slice right after it's come out of the oven. Feel free to wait around for 10-20 minutes for a fresh pie to come out -- it's worth it.
Parag Khandelwal
Less is more. Go for the margarita, and don't ruin it by putting your own toppings, except if it's their hot peppers.
Northern Spy Food Co
Just a great slice of NY pizza for when you're cruising up 1st Ave and need to nosh.
Talia Goldberg
Free, crushed, delicious homemade garlic spread is at the counter. You're a fool not to try it with your slice
Daniel Cintra
best slice in the city. get he regular
Jon Steinback
Great artisanal slice. A little pricey (in the four-dollar range), but fresh ingredients and lots of olive oil (not grease).
David X
This is one of the best pizza I've ever ate, maybe the best actually...fresh ingredients, the roasted garlic paste is amazing, the result is close to perfection just with the simple slice!!
Marie Bardi
They have delicious calzones but only during the daytime
Dan Kalafus
Fresh ingredients - even fresh garlic and real grated Parmesan. The bar has been raised...
Connie K
Great pizza. Get the sicilian slice, top it with baked garlic and freshly grated cheese! everything is so fresh and tasty :)
Mary Pilon
On par or better than Artichoke. Load up with fresh garlic and mozzarella and try to time so you get a fresh slice right outta the oven. Tape it to your thighs!
Ill Literate
Don't miss the amazing home made roasted garlic paste. This place is amazing.
The oven suits the name: a reconfigured 1950s bread oven scavenged from an old Bensonhurst bagelry. Neapolitan pies after 6 only. 24/7 delivery soon.
Venue data powered by foursquare foursquare