Served in an Irish coffee glass, this drink is one of the most popular hot drinks on the menu at New Leaf Restaurant & Bar (other than their infamous hot chocolate). With flavors reminiscent of a slice of warm apple pie, people have said drinking one of these is “like slippin’ into a warm slipper…” — Allison Beck
Pour rum into a 10-ounce glass. Add the hot apple cider and cinnamon stick. Stir briefly to mix, then top with whipped cream and serve.