The Nutty Irishman Cocktail

The Nutty Irishman Cocktail
From, by Barb Kiebel

The Nutty Irishman Cocktail Photo

I love St. Patrick’s Day or St. Paddy’s Day (but never St. Patty’s Day!), the annual celebration of all things Irish. Irish or not it’s all about having a great time and I’m absolutely on-board with that. My grandfather on my mom’s side was part Irish so I’m legitimate, but not that I need an excuse; don’t we all think we’re a tiny bit Irish on St. Patrick’s Day?

Maybe that’s why the only beer I enjoy is Guinness? Still, no green beer for me; I lean way more towards cocktails made with coffee, Irish Whiskey, and Bailey’s, and in the case of this cocktail today? How about all three! Not wanting to be redundant of things I’ve created in the past, I decided to throw in some Frangelico hazelnut liqueur and bring a bit of Italy into the mix; how could that ever be bad?

Want to get into the spirit with me? If you think St. Patrick’s Day is just another one of those days that was elevated only in America; think again. There's a video on YouTube of a parade held in the streets of Dublin - search for "St. Patrick's Day Parade - Dublin" to find it. While Denver has an annual St. Patrick’s Day Parade downtown, trust me, it doesn’t even begin to compare.

The Nutty Irishman Cocktail Picture

I also love making a meal with dishes I consider Irish and this cabbage and bacon colcannon with Irish whiskey steak is a huge favorite. Cabbage in mashed potatoes? Don’t knock until you’ve tried it; it is so good, and of course the bacon doesn’t hurt the cause one tiny bit! For dessert each year I don’t get too adventurous; we simply love this ‘Irish coffee’ cake.

Not to be confused with a breakfast treat; this cake has both coffee and Irish Whiskey; you know, those components of an Irish Coffee? Hence the moniker and it’s quite simply the perfect sweet ending to a meal with corned beef, shepherd’s pie or the aforementioned colcannon. I might have to make all three!

While wanting something that included ingredients from the Land of the Blarney-stone, I’m not so keen on green; preferring to not include a jar of green food coloring in the process or an artificially colored and flavored liqueur. Not mentioning any names - Creme de Menthe - but unless mint is somehow the national plant of Ireland I wasn’t buying that it was a ‘have to.’

The Nutty Irishman Cocktail Image

I decided instead to make this cocktail; a play on an Irish coffee, which is a combination of strong coffee and Jameson Irish Whiskey topped with whipped cream. Of course you could use any Irish Whiskey, but Jameson is an iconic brand and I think perfect for this cocktail. There are stronger and probably even better Irish whiskeys but those are more suitable for sipping and I think Jameson perfect for either baking or cocktail-making.

I know of no good substitute for Bailey’s, which is an Irish whiskey and cream liqueur. I’ve made my own, but it does have a short shelf life, so unless I’m making a batch to give away for holiday gifts, I actually prefer buying a small bottle of Bailey’s when the need arises.

Frangelico hazelnut liqueur is the wild card of this bunch, hailing from Italy - and it’s one of my favorites. Made from Tonda Gentile hazelnuts that are grown in an area of rural hills and picturesque villages in the southern Piedmont of Italy; they are known for being bigger, plumper and more uniform with a skin that sheds easily, making them perfect for toasting without leaving a bitter taste. Once toasted and distilled with alcohol, the hazelnuts are combined with other flavors including cocoa, coffee and vanilla according to a secret recipe and transformed into Frangelico.

Bringing it all together in a rich and warm cocktail? Priceless. A hardship for me too, though and it wasn’t fair. I finished the photos for this post in the evening and without a St. Patrick’s Day Party on the agenda at that moment; I decided it would be best if I didn’t imbibe the coffee at 9pm. Things did improve the next day though. I had it for breakfast! 


The Nutty Irishman Cocktail Recipe



  • 3 ounces irish whiskey
  • 2 ounces irish cream
  • 2 ounces frangelico
  • 2 cups coffee, strong and freshly brewed

For Garnish:

  • whipped cream
  • nutmeg


  1. Warm your coffee mugs by pouring some hot water into them and letting them sit for a minute before filling them with the cocktail.
  2. Pour the liquor and liqueurs into the warmed coffee mug or Irish coffee glass.
  3. Fill with the coffee and stir well.
  4. Top with the whipped cream and dust with ground nutmeg.
Rate this Story