The Lobster Roll Restaurant

Row 1

1980 Montauk Hwy
Amagansett, NY 11930
(631) 267-3740
$ $
Mon–Sun: 11:30 AM–9:30 PM


Foursquare Tips

  • If you're feeling ambitious, bike here from East (or even South) Hampton for lunch. It's all about the lobster roll and fries.
  • Order the lobster thing on menu!
  • . . .
  • Definitely try the puffer fish. The seafood Mac n' cheese is on the smaller side but is LOADED with seafood.
  • You cannot go to Montauk without stopping at the world famous LUNCH Lobster Roll!
  • Puffers are super delish when they are in season. Mini and deep and deep fried for dipping.
  • Awesome food! Most amazing lobster roll and clam strips ever!
  • In truth, it's all about the lobster roll here and the fruit pies. Everything else is hit or miss. Drinks so so.
  • Yum. Buttered hot lobster roll is my preference
  • Huge chunks of lobster. (Go with the classic cold lobster roll) Cole slaw was a surprise power player.
  • If you're driving out to Montauk and don't stop here on the way, you're missing out. This spot has one of the best lobster rolls around, and some seriously awesome strawberry rhubarb pie.
  • Everyone is talking bout the Lob*ter Roll. Get the Puffers and Chips! S'like... shrimp made out of fish, well, actually, it's boneless blowfish. This is outstanding!
  • Check in on yelp for a free beer
  • The Lobster Rolls are obviously fantastic but the real gem here is the Cole Slaw. I know it's ridiculous considering the whole menu rocks but its seriously spectacular!
  • Tasty tasty. Pricey pricey.
  • Order the lobster roll with butter. Delicious.
  • no oysters on the half shell?
  • free mimosas for moms on mothers day ... highly suggested to borrow a wallet full of pics of a friend's kid ;-)
  • have a lobster roll, then the strawberry rhubarb pie... pat yourself on the back and smile.
  • They have an entire gluten free menu for those looking for such things, including lobster rolls and cupcakes!