Duryea's Lobster Deck & Seafood Market

Row 1

65 Tuthill Rd
Montauk, NY 11954
(631) 668-2410
$ $ $
Mon–Sat: 9:00 AM–8:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Incredibly over-priced. Lobster by the pound is way down, has been for over 2-years, yet prices keep soaring? Not cool. Overall, food is good, great, friendly service and a killer view.
  • Best lobster salad roll EVER.
  • aside from the killer sunset locale, totally over-priced, overrated & disappointing. maybe it was better when it was "off the radar"
  • Bring a bottle of ros to Duryeas, set on a rocky Montauk outcropping and renowned for its well-priced lobster. Just be prepared for a long wait.
  • BYOB...great lobster roll, if not a touch too bready. Amazing steamed cherrystones with garlic butter yum yum!!
  • Go for the view. Bring cash & YOB. Avoid the oysters. Go for the lobster roll, like everyone says
  • One-of-a-kind place to really Eat Out for lunch or dinner. Order your food inside, grab a table out on the deck, or take it to go. They only serve soft beverages, no alcohol.
  • The lobster rolls have very little mayo. It's all lobster.
  • Lobster roll and the view !!
  • Nice food, great location, after the rebuild also way, way too pricey.
  • This was my favorite place in Montauk. It's situated on the water & offers amazing views during sunset. We had the clam bake & lobster w a side of corn but it comes w corn! The dish was amaze + ros.
  • Killer views.
  • This is the last season owned by original owners, so now is the time to try it. Lobster roll is best on the peninsula. Clam chowder is outstanding. Service is quick and efficient.
  • Enjoy it while you can before it turns into a proper restaurant. Bring beer to drink while waiting for your table and dress warm.
  • Perfect location for a lobster role
  • The clam chowder is amazing. Skip the scallops, they're overpriced, overcooked and they're small pieces.
  • Byob and fresh fish. Perfect for a Hamptons summer night. Come early to avoid long waits and surprisingly cold night breezes.
  • Duryea's has fallen victim to the over popularity of Montauk. Once a reasonably priced place to have a great lobster. Now a ridiculously overpriced trap for drunken weekenders.
  • Great sunset view!
  • This place rules! Cash only and BYOB so plan ahead. Lobster roll or some crab or whatever its all good. Quiet spot