J.J. Gandy’s supplies pies to over 20 local restaurants in the Tampa Bay area and has been a local favorite for 27 years. You can pick up a huge variety of pies year-round, but certain flavors take over during the holiday season. Since Thanksgiving is the store’s busiest holiday, with over 3,000 orders being filled annually, plan to order your pie as early as possible. Double-crusted fruit pies, such as apple, Dutch apple and cherry, must be ordered at least 24 hours in advance of pick-up. Other pie flavors are kept in stock, but it is still best to place an order and reserve your pie. Holiday pie flavors include pecan pie, pumpkin cheese pie, mincemeat pie and the most popular – pumpkin chiffon pie, a lighter, fluffier version than traditional pumpkin pie.
Mike’s pies are so good that they have made their way into restaurants in 25 states and have even been featured on the Food Network. His pies have won 13 awards and his key lime pie recipe is locally famous. Key lime pie may seem like a summery treat, but hundreds are ordered during the holidays as well. If key lime is not for you, try the southern pecan pie, pumpkin pie or the granny apple crisp pie, made with tart granny apples and a sweet and crunchy streusel.
The most popular flavor from Wright’s is pecan pie. The buttery, flaky crust, sweet custard and roasted pecans used in the pie are hard to beat. You can also order other popular holiday flavors such as pumpkin, apple crumb pies and apple lattice pies. An assortment of pies are always kept in stock, but to avoid the disappointment of your favorite flavor being sold out, order ahead to reserve your pie.
Related: Best Autumn Desserts In Tampa Bay
Typically, Chocolate Pi specializes in elaborate wedding and birthday cakes. However, during the holidays, you can find some seasonal pie favorites. Pie flavors you’ll be thankful for include pecan, apple, lemon and chocolate, as well as a delectable pumpkin cheesecake. Order several days in advance to be sure you get the pie you want.
Most of the year, Pane Rustica doesn’t do pies. You’d find other types of desserts, such as cookies and pastries, instead. However, during the holiday season, Pane Rustica whips up some seasonal favorites. Some of your choices include pumpkin pie, pumpkin cheesecake, apple and cranberry-blueberry. Be sure to reserve your favorite flavor in advance.
Related: Best Pumpkin Treats In Tampa Bay