America's Most Outrageous Ice Cream Sandwiches Slideshow

Slide 1 of 10
Rainbow Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich — Donatella, New York City

This pizzeria from celebrity chef Donatella Arpaia is known for serving up stellar desserts, courtesy of pastry chef Andrea Jarosh. Their ice cream sandwich begins with rainbow cookies (also known as tri-color cookies), which are available in most Italian bakeries. The consistency is similar to almond-flavored cake, with a thin spread of chocolate ganache between each layer. Homemade vanilla gelato is used as the filling.