7 Best New Year’s Eve Dinners In NYC

7 Best New Year’s Eve Dinners In NYC

Everyone knows that New York City is one of the best places to dine out. But where do you go on New Year’s Eve when you want to celebrate with a special meal? We’ve narrowed down our favorite restaurants so all you have to do is make a reservation and show up. By Carly Petrone.


(credit: mckittrickhotel.com)

The McKittrick Hotel

530 W. 27th St.
New York, NY


Save to foursquare

div.vcard div.foursquare > div { margin-top: 1em; }


More: Best Places To Go Dancing In New York

Attend The King’s Midnight Feast at The McKittrick Hotel this New Year’s Eve. Don your best black or gold outfit and sit down to a royal feast at Gallow Green & The Heath followed by a midnight masquerade celebration. There will be live performances and an open bar all night long. Hurry, tickets are going fast! Be a part of Maximillan’s List and enjoy exclusive access to the Captain’s Quarters during the masquerade. Event begins at 11 p.m. and tickets are $400.


(Credit: Facebook/CatchNYC)


21 Ninth Ave.
New York, NY


Save to foursquare

More: NYC’s 5 Best Restaurants For Seafood & Drinks

Seafood lovers will want to book their reservation for a special New Year’s Eve dinner at Catch. Whether it’s a date night or a group gathering, you can get the party started with some seriously good eats including Oysters with Mango Yuzu-Caviar, Dover Sole with Maitake, Leeks, and Citrus Brown Butter Sauce, and Rice Cakes topped with Crispy Shrimp. For those looking for something heartier, try the Filet Mignon with Caramelized Onion Potato Cake and a Red Wine Reduction Sauce or the Potato Gnocchi garnished with Black Truffle and Brioche. You’ll be ready to ring in 2015 with a full and happy stomach.


(credit: Facebook/Carmines)


200 W. 44th St.
New York, NY


Save to foursquare

More: NYC’s Best Family-Style Italian Restaurants

Enjoy New Year’s Eve in the heart of Times Square at Carmine’s Italian restaurant. This iconic eatery in the theater district will be hosting three types of celebrations – The New Year’s Eve Premium Package ($600), the New Year’s Eve Package ($400), and the New Year’s Eve Bar Package ($250). The Premium Package includes a four hour premium open bar, passed hors d’oeuvres, a buffet loaded with their signature dishes, a live DJ performance, a televised broadcast of the Times Square ball drop, as well as a reserved private table with a complimentary bottle of Carmine’s Private Label Prosecco. The New Year’s Eve Package includes all of the above minus the private table and prosecco while the Bar Package includes admission to the bar and dance floor as well as buffet and dessert from 9 p.m. – 1 a.m. Have fun in Times Square without all the chaos of the crowds.


(credit: sotto13.com)

Sotto 13

140 W. 13th St.
New York, NY


Save to foursquare

More: The 7 Best Cheap Eats In The West Village

If you’re craving an Italian meal with a twist, head over to Sotto 13 in the West Village. Chef Ed Cotton is hosting a two-part New Year’s Eve party. From 5 p.m. – 8 pm. diners can enjoy a four-course dinner with a menu that is perfect for the adventurous eater. Nosh on Truffled Beef Tartare with Quail Egg and Parmesan on a Crostini, or Chestnuts and Chicken Lasagna with Creamy Spinach, Wild mushrooms and Fontina Cheese. Top it off with some Warm Confetti Bomboloni (fried doughnut holes) with warm Nutella-Chocolate Sauce and head out for the night. Or stick around for a cocktail party starting at 10 p.m. with a complete open bar, passed small plates (think lemon-saffron arancini with smoked mozzarella and crispy chicken wing lollipops in agrodolce sauce) and a live DJ.

 Facebook/Colicchio & Sons)

(credit: Facebook/Colicchio & Sons)

Colicchio & Sons

85 Tenth Ave.
New York, NY


Save to foursquare

More: The 5 Best Cocktail Bars In Chelsea

Enjoy a champagne toast and a prix fixe menu at Colicchio & Sons this New Year’s Eve. Make your reservation for one of two seating times (5 p.m. – 6:30 p.m. and 7:30 p.m. – 11 p.m.) The first seating includes a four-course menu ($155/person) with everything from Roasted Octopus and Chilled Main Lobster as appetizers to Pancetta Wrapped Monkfish and 20-day Dry-Aged Sirloin for the main course. Choose from four different desserts like the chocolate caramel tart, buttermilk panna cotta, butterscotch glazed doughnuts, or the dark chocolate semifreddo. The second service ($220/person) has a menu for the real foodie – Wild Sturgeon Caviar with Chive Crème Fraiche and Egg Yolk, Roasted Foie Gras, Guinea Hen with Black Truffle, Wheat Berries, and Winter Greens, and Milk-Fed Porchetta with Mustard Braised Carrots, Black Trumpet Mushrooms, and Dates.


(credit: atriumdumbo.com)


15 Main St.
Brooklyn, NY


Save to foursquare

More: Brooklyn’s 5 Best Bars Off the Beaten Path

Brooklynites looking for a fancy feast can make their reservation for one of two seatings at Atrium in Dumbo. The first seating starts out with a goat cheese & beet crostini, foie gras Torchon, and Montauk Pearl Oyster with Caviar as appetizers before moving onto a Nova Scotia Lobster Salad. For the main course, you can choose between a housemade Potato Gnocchi, Butter Poached Turbot, or New Zealand Rack of Venison. Satisfy your sweet tooth with their chocolate & coffee cremeux. At $85 per person, this holiday meal is reasonably priced for such a decadent edible experience. Add on a wine pairing for an additional $40/person. Stick around for the second seating ($115) and celebrate the New Year with a free champagne toast at midnight.

 Facebook/Tavern on the Green)

(credit: Facebook/Tavern on the Green)

Tavern on the Green

67th and Central Park West
New York, NY


Save to foursquare

More: The 5 Best Bars Near Central Park

It doesn’t get anymore New York than dining at Tavern on the Green in Central Park. Celebrate the last night of 2014 at one of the most iconic spots in the city at the Tavern on the Green New Year’s Eve Ball! Starting at 9 p.m., you can enjoy live performances by both a jazz band and a DJ while grand fireworks display over the park at midnight. Your $325 ticket includes a four-hour open bar, passed hors d’oeuvres, and party favors. Buck up for the Platinum VIP package ($500) and you’ll get a great private table with a Central Park view, a bottle of champagne or vodka, and access to a raw bar tray. Grab your ticket before it’s too late!

For the latest on all of the Tri-State’s events and happenings, follow us on Twitter!

Carly Petrone is a freelance writer living in New York City.

Rate this Story