5 Favorite New York City Spots for a Negroni
Today on The Daily Meal
- Cook and Janitor of Nursing Home Kept Working without Pay Because 'If We Left, They Wouldn't Have Nobody'
- Outpouring of Appreciation for Cook and Janitor Who Stayed Behind at Shuttered Nursing Home (and How You Can Help)
- America’s Unhealthiest Fast Foods
- Best Turkey Tips for Thanksgiving
- 8 Irish Whiskies Beyond Jameson
For whatever reason, the Negroni has become the bartender’s favorite tipple. From Munich to Manhattan, Sydney to San Francisco, it is the one universal cocktail that we barkeeps tend to drink after work, on our nights off, before dinner, at a BBQ... Heck, whenever the moment calls for something bright, complex, and soothing, there isn’t a mixed drink on the planet that carries the industry cache that this bright red and bitter elixir does.
Maybe it’s the simplicity of its preparation. Maybe it’s that unique mix of spice, bitterness, and sweetness that only comes when gin, Campari, and sweet vermouth get together for a party. Or perhaps it’s just the fact that we like drinking things that most of the population doesn’t. Campari, for one, could most certainly be considered an acquired taste. (Although if they made Campari-flavored toothpaste, I’d use it. I’m a little weird.)
The Negroni originated in Florence, Italy around 1919, just as Prohibition was rearing its ugly head on our shores. As thirsty Americans flocked to Europe, the city’s alfresco cafés and bars were teeming with strange elixirs like the Americano and, eventually, the Negroni. It was named after Count Camillo Negroni, who would stop off at the Caffe Cassoni where bartender Fosco Scarselli would make him a curious mix of gin, Campari, and vermouth. A legend was born.
Now, as is the common practice among today's bartenders, many are putting their own individual spin on this iconic drink. I ventured around town to see what some of our finest are doing to their Negronis. For the cocktail purists among us, turn away now.
At Michael White’s ode to the hearty cuisine of Emilia Romagna, bar manager and drink-slinger Richard Ervin has compiled a wonderful menu of five Negronis, each based on a different spirit. You can, of course, stick with a classic version spiked with Tanqueray and Carpano Antica vermouth or you might prefer something laced with reposado tequila, dark rum, or rye. All are stellar, although I did enjoy the Bianco on my last visit (pictured above), which features Junipero gin, Cocchi Americano, and Gran Classico Bitter, standing in admirably for the Campari.
Gabe Stulman’s expansion deeper into the West Village continues at this hip new subterranean joint where a monstrous bar runs the length of the entire room. It’s a fine piece of mahogany from where you might enjoy, like I did, their barrel-aged Negroni, which follows a popular trend of bartenders experimenting with the wood's influence on their cocktails. Delicious!
When day turns to night and plates of antipasti crowd the tables at this West Village staple, owner Joe Campanale might suggest his own take on a Negroni Sbagliato, which translates literally as "Wrong Negroni." The drink was apparently created in 1972 at Milan’s Bar Basso when the bartender reached for a bottle of Prosecco instead of the usual gin, and thus a low-octane, highly refreshing variation was born. Campanale's twist incorporates a muddled wedge of roasted orange, adding its own toasty nuance.
Husband and wife team Avery and Janet Glasser started out as a couple of cocktail geeks, making their own bitters at home, which eventually led them to creating special blends for some of the city’s top barkeeps. Now they have a retail outlet that doubles as a bar. Amor Y Amargo ("Love and Bitters") on Sixth Street is a tiny hole-in-the-wall dishing up all manner of bitter treats including their "Bespoke Negroni." I let Avery take the reins one night and what was presented included Red Breast Irish whiskey, Cocchi Americano, and Aperol. Hardly a Negroni by any stretch, but it sure was tasty.
In a setting where you’re more likely to get a killer Mai Tai — replete with all the kitschy trimmings — owner Richie Boccato will also knock you up a frozen Negroni. Only available for another month or two before the chill sets in, it is a surprisingly delightful respite from our stinky and sweaty New York summer. It’s nice to see a little fun and whimsy put back into the serious world of modern mixology.
And for one of my own creations, I present the Chocolate Negroni. It's not as weird as it sounds if you consider that orange (the classic Negroni garnish) and chocolate have long been friends in the patissier’s world. This drink combines Plymouth gin, Punt e Mes vermouth (very bold, spicy, and rich), Campari, and a whisper each of white crème de cacao and chocolate mole bitters. Stirred lovingly and served on a giant ice cube, perhaps with an orange blossom foam for garnish and texture.
Be a Part of the Conversation
Join the Daily Meal's Community and Share your Thoughts